Best Explosimeter & Combustible Gas Detector (Expert Analysis)

Combustible Gas Detector, Combustibles Meter, Explosimeter, Flammable Gas Detector, Gas Leak Detector -

Best Explosimeter & Combustible Gas Detector (Expert Analysis)

An explosimeter is an electronic gas meter that detects combustibles, flammable gases and volatile vapors. These instruments are used to assess gas and vapor for volatility, flammability and provides a good indication of the vapor pressure on a relative basis. These units are commonly used in the oil and gas industry, petrochemical industry, refining industry, R&D and industrial processing.

Pros

Cons

  • Explosimeters are useful tools for fast volatile gas or vapor analysis.
  • The MSA Explosimeter series has served the industry well since 1940.
  • New version of the explosimeter have been innovated with all inclusive micro-pump (no need for the traditional hand pump, aspirator). 
  • Explosimeters and combustible gas detectors do not discriminate between the hundreds of different volatile gases and vapors.
  • These units typically employ catalytic pellistor type sensors and require at least 10% of oxygen for reliable measurement.
  • Explosimeters require calibration between 6 to 12 months and last from 2 to 4 years.

What Is a Explosimeter?

A explosimeter is an electronic gas meter that detects combustibles, flammable gases and volatile vapors. These instruments are used to assess gases and vapor for volatility, flammability and provides a good indication of the vapor pressure on a relative basis. These units are commonly used in the oil and gas industry, petrochemical industry, refining industry, R&D and industrial processing. An Explosimeter is also called a combustible gas detector, flammable gas detector, combustible gas detector, gas leak detector or flammable gas analyzer.

What is the difference between an Explosimeter and a Combustible Gas Detector?

There is no difference. 

Traditionally, the word explosimeter was coined and trademarked by MSA in 1940. Over the many decades of its use, it has become a synonym for a Combustible Gas Detector. Flammable Gas Analyzer is also used to describe a Explosimeter or Combustible Gas Detector.

What Does an Explosimeter Detect?

An explosimeter detects combustible gases and vapors in air. In other words, it detects the presence of flammable gases and vapors. In doing so, it provides a indication if the atmosphere is dangerous.

If the combustible gas or vapor is a high boiling point solvent, a relatively low vapor concentration will be detected. If the temperature increase, the combustible will be more volatile, and hence, the vapor concentration will increase, hence increase the explosimeter %LEL reading.

Does it detect Explosive Dusts?

No it does not. 

An explosimeter does not detect the explosivity of combustible mists or sprays. It does not detector explosive dusts such as grain or coal dust.

What is the difference between an Explosimeter and a Tankscope?

A Tankscope is very similar to a Explosimeter in that both detect combustible gases and vapors.

Traditionally, the Tankscope was designed by MSA to detect combustibles in an inert environment - which means an environment deprived of oxygen.

A typical combustible gas detector (and explosimeter) requires at least 10% of oxygen to correctly operate. However, due to the operate and sensor selection of the Tankscope, it can detector combustibles in an inert environment, such as a large tank or silo.

In addition, the Tankscope reading is an absolute reading, showing %volume. The explosimeter presents to the user, the detected concentration as a %LEL reading.

What Are Explosimeters Used for?

Gas and Vapor Sample Analysis

This units are used to determine the volatility of a sample liquid. This is typically used in the oil and gas industry and in R&D. This serves as a fast qualitative measure of a "relative" volatility. The EX LEL% can be calibrated to known liquid vapor pressures, however, the size of the sample vial, temperature, liquid volume and agitation are all key factors to consider. 

explosimeter msa combustible gas indicator reading

RKI EX LEL

Personal Protection

The majority of combustible gas detectors are used for personal protection and commonly used in confined spaces to ensure safety. These units are small and portable, battery-powered units.

combustible gas indicator

Gooseneck Combustible Gas Leak Detectors

Gas Leak detectors are also combustible gas detectors. However, the difference is (a) typically gas leak detectors present the user with a ppm combustible value (calibrated to methane). So, it is a much more sensitive measurement compared to a %LEL. In addition, these unit employ FIGARO type semiconducting oxide sensors.

gas leak detector combustibles indicator 

Fixed Wall Combustible Monitors 

Wall-mounted units provide continuous protection and alarm if a dangerous flammable environment exists. These units are important for storage facilities, work facilities, process and manufacturing areas.

fixed wall mount H2S monitor

How do Volatile Liquids Create An Explosive Environment?

Combustible and flammable liquids may off-gas or vaporize that will then produce a flammable environment. These liquids may be petrochemical products such as diesel, gasoline, isopropanol and many other hydrocarbon flammable liquids.

Molecules will off-gas when they have enough energy (thermal) to overcome the intermolecular forces holding them in the liquid or solid phase. Indeed, variables such as agitation and temperature add to the energy component that may further enhance off-gassing or vaporization. In doing so, these gas molecules produce a pressure on the liquid or solid (within a sealed container). This is known as the vapor pressure. So in other words, the higher the vapor pressure, the more off-gas or vapor exists in the atmosphere. Liquids with higher vapor pressures have a lower flash point and are therefore more flammable.

Interestingly, this phenomena occurs all around us. Think of when you are filling up your car at the gas station. One can often smell the gasoline vapors. The molecules originate in the liquid state. Then, enter the gas phase and are then detected by ones nose. If enough gasoline molecules accumulate within a volume of space, it may be enough to create a flammable environment, and hence the important of the EX LEL scale (see below).

explosimeter flammable gas combustible gas

How Does an Explosimeter Work?

An explosimeter or combustible gas detector is composed of electronics and combustible catalytic bead sensor. The gas sensor converts the detected gas concentration to an electronic signal. This electronic signal is processed and compared to a calibration graph (gradient) which then finally displays the corresponding EX LEL% concentration reading. 

The most important component of the meter is the sensor.

Explosimeters and combustible gas and vapor detectors employ a catalytic bead sensor, often referred to as a pellistor sensor or filament. This element detects combustibles by oxidizing or “burning” the combustible gas on an active bead. The heating effect changes the sensor's conductivity, which is proportional to the amount of combustible gas detected. Integrated with a heating element to operate at about 500F, this device is often very small. The sensor contains two beads, one active and one not. It is typically placed in a Wheatstone bridge configuration. 

pellister catalytic bead combustibles sensor

 

Combustibles Sensor Technology

Working Principle

Pros

Cons

Catalytic Bead Pellister Sensor Combustible gas oxidizes on the bead, changing the conductivity of the element. The resistance change is
proportional to the combustible concentration.
  • Low cost
  • Very reliable & simple
  • 2 to 4 year lifespan
  • Best for %LEL range
  • Not selective
  • Consumes power for heating
  • Requires startup time for heating
  • Not for high % absolute volume  since 10% of O2 is required

      What Is the Best Explosimeter?

      There are many Combustible Gas Detectors. But there is only one Explosimeter (from MSA). The reputable brands of combustible gas detectors include the following:

      flammable gas analyzer combustible gas detector

        How Long Does a Flammable Gas Detector last for?

          Combustible Gas Detectors employ catalytic bead pellistor type sensors that last up from 2 to 4 years.

          How Do I Test My Explosimeter?

          The best way to test your Combustible Gas Detector is via a Bump test. Bump testing is good practice to perform daily. This task exposes the detector to some combustible gas such as methane. Frequent testing is especially important in personal protection applications where safety is paramount.

          How do I Calibrate a Flammable Gas Detector?

          All explosimeters, combustible gas detectors and similar, all require periodic calibration. Calibration is required to ensure accurate gas readings. Over time, the sensors on the device will degrade or produce drifting readings. We suggest calibrating your detector every 6 to 12 months. See more info here on calibration.

          Be attentive and calibrate more often (daily) if:

          • The unit is being used as an analytical tool where accuracy is paramount.
          • The instrument is in extreme environment (temp and humidity extremes create sensor drift).
          • The user is performing an imminently dangerous application. Sampling a tank or silo situation, bump and calibration before use.
          • Bump testing fails. 
          • The meter is alarming erratically in the fresh air. This could mean that the sensor has drifted past an alarm set-point.

          Also here are some precautionary items also:

          • Calibration and bump testing are mandatory because injury or death can occur if the device fails.
          • Have a calibration schedule. Ensure correct training. See gas calibration here.

            Final Words

            • An Explosimeter is an electronic gas meter that detects combustibles, flammable gases and volatile vapors. 
            • An Explosimeter is also called a combustible gas detector, flammable gas detector, combustible gas detector, gas leak detector or flammable gas analyzer.
            • These instruments are used to assess gas and vapor for volatility, flammability and provides a good indication of the vapor pressure on a relative basis.
            • These units are commonly used in the oil and gas industry, petrochemical industry, refining industry, R&D and industrial processing.
            • The MSA Explosimeter series has served the industry well since 1940.
            • A new version of the explosimeter has been innovated with an all inclusive micro-pump (no need for the traditional hand pump, aspirator) and costs less than $400.

            About The Author

            Dr. Koz is the President of FORENSICS DETECTORS, where the company operates from the scenic Palos Verdes Peninsula in Los Angeles, California. He is a subject matter expert on gas sensor technology, gas detectors, gas meters, and gas analyzers. He has been designing, building, manufacturing, and testing toxic gas detection systems for over 20 years.

            gas detector expert

            Every day is a blessing for Dr. Koz. He loves to help customers solve their unique problems. Dr. Koz also loves spending time with his wife and his three children going to the beach, grilling burgers, and having a cold beer. 

            Read more about Forensics Detectors here.

            Email:  drkoz@forensicsdetectors.com
            Phone: +1 424-341-3886

             

             


            Leave a comment

            Please note, comments must be approved before they are published